×

Where do the Cardinals go from here?

By Scott Plaza Sep 10, 2026 | 12:00 PM
Sep 7, 2026; San Francisco, California, USA; St. Louis Cardinals pitcher Riley O’Brien (61) reacts against the San Francisco Giants during the tenth inning at Oracle Park. Mandatory Credit: John Hefti-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Well. Another pathetic showing from a St. Louis Cardinals bullpen resulted in a series sweep against a mediocre opponent. This team has constantly shown it plays to the level of their competition, but the series against the Giants went too far.

After winning five of their last six series on the road, including taking the season series against the Dodgers, the Cardinals had momentum against the miserable Giants only to see the season pretty much come to an end in San Francisco. To get over the emotions this three-game set made me feel, I dusted off the podcast equipment and finally recorded a new episode of Cardinals on My Time.

Joining me on the episode was returning guest Matt Blaker, and nothing against Matt, but I was pumped to have Tanner Larkins joining the pod as well. Chances are, you have no idea who that is and I just came across his profile earlier this week. Tanner is the front man for a band called Bayview Lane and his two singles instantly caught my attention. Add on the fact he was rocking a Cardinals hat in his videos while being from the Chicago area like me, he was the perfect guest to have on with Matt and me.

EPISODE TRANSCRIPT

Cardinals bullpen failure was the plan all along for Chaim Bloom

In the episode, we talked about the rollercoaster ride of the season, roster management, but also focused on the future. To me, the most frustrating point of this season was the roster management, be it playing short-handed through injuries or with a seemingly always “taxed” bullpen. The bullpen conversation was made worse after this series, but the problems revert all the way back to the offseason despite the early season success and breakout of certain guys.

One thing we talked about was that this bullpen creation, or lack thereof, was done intentionally. That is one of the more upsetting things to me (and keep your “this is a rebuild” comments to yourself) because this was a clear hole all year. Of course, bullpens are a crapshoot every year, but you’re telling me adding another one or two higher profile relievers would prevent the rebuild from happening? Worst case scenario, you pull the plug on those arms in a season that doesn’t matter, middle case, you flip them at the deadline, best case, you’re actually competing for a playoff spot instead of blowing 37 leads.

We finished the episode by comparing the Cardinals to the White Sox, who are competing for a division title despite losing 100 games back-to-back seasons. With that, I brought up the question for how aggressive Bloom needs to be in 2027 (yes there will be a season) to make sure the team capitalizes on their young players’ primes.

The series against the Giants was the final nail in the coffin, but I will still be interested in seeing what guys like Leo Bernal and Joshua Baez can do, or if Thomas Saggese can fix the hole at third base. I would like to see some more of the young arms get a shot in the last couple weeks so I will still be connected on a near-daily basis.

It was good to get back on the podcast train and I hope to get back on it more consistently here soon. (Great timing, Scott, since the season is over). If you enjoy the show or the content, please give me a subscribe on Spotify, Apple, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts and join me over on Twitter.

Finally, please give Tanner some love on his new music linked below. If you’re in the Chicago/Milwaukee area, make sure you take a look at Tanner’s schedule to see him play some live shows!

Thanks as always!